Pre-rendered game demos at E3
I must admit to being very impressed by the Killzone 2 trailer from E3 (http://www.gametrailers.com/gamepage.php?id=1668). It invoked a similar response to the one I experienced when Bungie released the first Halo trailers - I was seriously impressed and sold on the whole concept. The action, the detail and the effects just blew me away. Once again, I was ready to embrace the concept of FPS on a console. Moreover, the apparent power of the PS3 was impressive.
I own an XBox, but I am not a fan of FPS games on consoles. The screen resolution is too low (I want to see more detail) and I find controllers a very poor substiture for a keyboard and mouse. I think HDTV and the high specs of next-gen consoles should go a long way to remedy some of my concerns.
But is the trailer pre-rendered? Is my enthusiasm misplaced? Is the whole thing too good to be true? Regrettably, it seems likely that it is pre-rendered. (http://ps3.ign.com/articles/616/616591p1.html) :(
This is very disappointing and quite frustrating. I find the whole process of showing off games for hardware that is not even in production antithetical to developing trust in a brand. Release the specs? Sure, go right ahead. But please, please don't use a pre-rendered movie to indicate to me what your game might look like when its finished and the hardware is ready.
Postscript:
I'm not saying that every game for the PS3 shown at E3 2005 was pre-rendered. I have good reason to believe that some games, at least, were running on hardware designed to emulate the specifications/features of the PS3.

1 Comments:
Here's the admission that the trailer is CGI ...
Arjan Brussee, Development Director of Guerilla Games wrote:
Paul,
Thank you for you email. I am glad to see that you are looking into the matter at hand rather than making false judgements. The video shown at E3 was not in real time. It was a CGI demo sped up from 5 FPS as you said. The development team did this because we could not make a demo of that calibur at 30-60 FPS on the hardware we had at the time. Now however, the team is working the game on PS3 alpha kits, and it is looking just as impressive as the demo, at 30 FPS. The game is still in the very early stages of development, and I expect that it will release with visuals that are just as impressive as those in the E3 demo. We are planning on showing in game footage before too long, and we can't wait to see the public's reaction to it.
Arjan Brussee
http://www.gameinsider.com/comments.php?id=1089&catid=1
Post a Comment
<< Home